Can We Save The World Logo  

 


USA flag This is the US site UK English web site content Click for UK site

Comparison of electric and other heating sources

The chart below shows the reduction in energy costs achieved by reducing furnace heating levels, using programmable thermostats, and using local electric radiant heaters.

Home heating - cost per day
Home heating options - daily costs
Click for a larger image

One might expect that using local radiant electric heaters would significantly increase the electrical energy used. The increase however is smaller than expected because the furnace, when operating, uses an electrically, typically 300 to 750 watt fan, to move the heated air. At lower thermostat temperatures the furnace fan is used less, the energy saved partly powers the electric heater.

Home heating energy cost reduction options
Home heating options - daily costs
Click for a larger image

For more information on this chart, reduce residential heating energy use.

Modern furnaces are usually, but not always, the most efficient for heating large areas.

Most US homes have the option of using electric or furnace generated heat. Using US average residential energy source costs, electrically generated heat is about 2½ (the Electric Gas Cost Ratio) times more expensive than natural gas powered furnace generated heat, however the Electric Gas Cost Ratio varies considerably from State to State. In Washington State in 2009 the Electric Gas Cost Ratio was 1.6, in Alaska it was 5!

US 2009 Residential Electricity and Natural Gas Costs by State A-M
Residential electricity and gas costs by State A-M
Click for a larger image

US 2009 Residential Electricity and Natural Gas Costs by State N-W
Residential Electricity and Natural Gas Costs by State N-W
Click for a larger image

As a starting approximation if the area of your home that you need to heat is less than the electric gas cost ratio use electric heat. You can refine this approximation by also referring to the information in US residential energy sources costs and efficiencies.

Electrically generated heat has three important and unique advantages: it can provide almost instant localized heat; it's efficiency remains constant compared with almost all other sources of heating; and maintenance costs are low.

Often the most efficient and lowest cost way to heat your home is to use programmable timer controlled furnace generated heat to provide modest temperature background heating, and use electricity to provide local focused heat in occupied areas.

Electric gas cost ratio

If your energy choices are electric vs natural gas and if the area you need to heat is less than 1/(the electric gas cost ratio) of the area heated by the furnace and ducting, electric heat is less expensive. However you should also factor in the type and age of your heating system.

Relative heating systems efficiencies
US residential heating sources efficiencies
Click for a larger image

If you only require local focused heat in a limited area of your home electrically generated heat is usually far more efficient than furnace generated heat. Thermostatically controlled electric radiant heaters provide almost immediate focussed heat, good comfort levels, and little maintenance to remain operational and efficient, some even have a built in humidifier.

Electrically heated oil filled radiators or electric convector heaters are an alternative but take longer to heat up and their heat is less focussed. Electric fan heaters are less efficient at providing local heat than the others mentioned electric as the heat produced is blown and distributed.

Considerable care is required if you use electric radiant heaters as they can cause fires if placed too close to combustible materials.

When using electric heaters more and natural gas or its alternatives less it should be remembered that most warm air heating systems use an electric powered blower which typically consumes 300 to 1000 watts, in consequence the additional electricity cost is somewhat offset.

Marvin radiant electric heater
Marvin radiant electric heater
Click for a larger image

Belling 2kW electric radiant heater
Belling 2kW electric radiant heater
Click for a larger image

Glen 2kW electric convector heater
Glen 2kw electric convector heater
Click for a larger image

Can we save the world logo